full-disclosure - Re: Announcing new security mailing list

lists.openwall.net		lists / announce john-users owl-users popa3d-users / xvendor oss-security / Bugtraq Full-Disclosure linux-kernel linux-netdev linux-ext4
Open Source and information security mailing list archives

Order Openwall GNU/*/Linux 2.0 on a CD with delivery worldwide

[<prev] [next>] [<thread-prev] [thread-next>] [month] [year] [list]

From: BlueBoar at thievco.com (Blue Boar)
Subject: Re: Announcing new security mailing list

Simon Richter wrote:
> To me, the term "full disclosure" does not mean "make it available as fast
> as possible", but rather "here is the information, expect it to leak in
> the next two weeks, so go out and fix the bug". The current bugtraq scheme
> enforces that, and I believe they are doing a great job.

There is no Bugtraq "scheme".  The Bugtraq moderator does not hold any 
posts.  The poster gets to decide when his informatino is released.  The 
people who post to Bugtraq as just as able to blindside a vendor as on any 
other mailing list.

The closest thing to what you describe that is offered by SecurityFocus is 
the vulnhelp service.  This is a way for someone who finds a bug to 
voluntarily dump the hassle of dealing with notifying the vendor and 
waiting onto the SecurityFOcus staff.  Someone who uses vulnhelp still 
wants to give the vendor advanced notice, they just don't want to do it 
themselves.  If they don't want the vendor to have any warning, they just 
post to Bugtraq.

						BB