Message-ID: <200605262311.k4QNB8LI013450@monkeys.highspeedweb.net>
Date: Sat, 27 May 2006 00:09:42 +0100
From: phugo@...hspeedweb.net
To: <thesinoda@...mail.com>, <bugtraq@...urityfocus.com>,
	<full-disclosure@...ts.grok.org.uk>
Subject: RE: [security] A Nasty Security Bug that affect PGP Virtual Disks & PGP SDA , PGP 8.x & 9.x and Truecrypt.


Hello,

I was reading your advisory (good work!), but I can't understand two things:

1) Are you saying that the key used to encrypt is fixed (it's not our
passphrase !?!?!), and your passphrase is just to access the disk, meaning,
just to control user access to the pgp disk ??? 

2) Can you copy the files and see it's content, or just list the content
inside the pgp disk ? You just say you can see the files, nothing about
their content unencrypted.

   If you can see the content, that would imply (or not ?) a fixed key
independent of you passphrase. Real scary stuff !
   I had thought something like this long time ago, but it made no sense to
me, since I assumed that the encryption key was my passphrase, so even if I
could subvert the authentication to the pgp disk, I couldn't decrypt
anything because I didn't had the encryption key. 

Regards,
Pedro


-----Original Message-----
From: security-bounces@...ts.seifried.org
[mailto:security-bounces@...ts.seifried.org] On Behalf Of
thesinoda@...mail.com
Sent: quarta-feira, 24 de Maio de 2006 21:56
To: bugtraq@...urityfocus.com
Subject: [security] A Nasty Security Bug that affect PGP Virtual Disks & PGP
SDA , PGP 8.x & 9.x and Truecrypt.

A Nasty Security Bug that affect PGP Virtual Disks & PGP SDA , PGP 8.x & 9.x
and Truecrypt. 

Affected Products:

    * PGP 8.x PGP 9.x maybe older version too

    * Truecrypt 4.2 maybe older version too

// Full detail can be found here //
<> http://www.safehack.com/Advisory/pgp/PGPcrack.html
<> http://www.safehack.com/Advisory/truecrypt/truecrypt.html

If you would like to watch the flash video check the following links.
<> pgpdiskvideo.html Tested on version 8.1 and the latest 9.02
   http://www.safehack.com/Advisory/pgp/pgpdiskvideo.html

<> truecrypt.html Tested on the latest version truecrypt-4.2.zip
   http://www.safehack.com/Advisory/truecrypt/truecrypt.html
   Note If you put stuff inside your test file you need to use a 
   debugger to extract the data. If you just follow the video you 
   will see how it is done without a debugger and an empty file.

The How?
========
I Was able to ACCESS PGP encrypted disks if the disk was encrypted with a
passphrase or a public Key. This method will work on both scary huh :-)

You need the followings tools:
------------------------------
   1. A Brain
   2. A Hex Editor.
   3. PGP 8.1 Entreprise or Personal. You can use 9.x too. My feeling is
this method will work on older versions too, because it is a design flaw in
PGP application not in PGP algorithm.
   4. A Debugger. Not needed if you wana backdoor pgp (olldbg)
   
During my tests I have found that PGP virtual DISK and PGP Self Extractable
file SDA have a SERIOUS security bug. I would rather say a design bug.

PGP disk or SDA can be cracked in 3 major steps:
------------------------------------------------
   1. Editing PGP protected file using a hex editor. (Patching the
passphrase).
   2. Tracing PGP protected file using a debugger. (You need a lot of time
and coding/cracking experience)
   3. Patching the responsible bytes.

I have spend only couples of days debugging but surely a lot more time is
needed. But once the process is understood it is question of finding the
right bytes and patching them.

 
Conclusions for 6 days debugging and testing:
=============================================
    * PGP Virtual Disk and PGP and PGP SDA has a serious bug. I have tested
PGP 8.1 Entreprise. Other version many be vulnerable too.

    * PGP corporation made the same error in PGP 9.x you can bypass the
passphrase Dialog box same way.

    * PGP corporation could avoid this type of issue by calculation the HASH
for the encrypted file. They should make it harder to locate the passphrase.

    * PGP Virtual Disk First Level protection bypass. Passphrase bypass.
(Working 100%)

    * PGP Virtual Disk Backdooring (Working 100%).

    * PGP Virtual Disk Mounting / Adding Users / Deleting Users /
Re-Encrypting Disk (Working 100%).

    * PGP Virtual Disk Mounting and Data Access (Working 40%. Need more time
to debug).

    * PGP SDA Passphrase bypass. (Working 100%)

    * PGP SDA Extraction is possible IF the input file is the same (Working
100% Patching using a Debugger)

    * PGP SDA Extraction is possible of any file (Working 80%. Need more
time to debug)

    * OTHER AFFECT PRODUCTS:
          o iOPUS Secure Email Attachments (SEA) V1.0
          o Truecrypt Free open-source disk encryption software 4.2

    * WINZIP was not affected. 1- In winzip you do not know where is the
password location 2- If you change one bit your file wont work

    * I DO NOT HAVE more time to test, but I am sure many smart dudes out
their would love to play some more.

    * To do: Build an application to mount PGP Virtual disk using this bug.

    * To do: Build an application to extract PGP SDA files using this bug.

After spending 6 days on this I had decided to stop. But I will be doing
more testing when I have some free time. You are free to do your own tests.
If you wish to share your own test or finding with me please feel free to
contact me at thesinoda@...mail.com


 
PGP SDA authentication method
=============================
Let's say you created a text file and wrote inside it "aa", then created an
SDA.
IF you hex edit the output exe, you will notice at the very buttom of the
file some bytes seperated by 803E.
Ex:

E7 93 A0 90 E9 62 D1 21
803E
A1 50 AF 5F 6F 9E FE D6

Analysing the bytes carefully, you will notice that 803E is the value used
for a loop. The loop starts at 0040590D. Further analysis showed that the
bytes right before 803E, are used for extraction and authentication.
Authentication is done in the following way:

When some enters a passphrase a series of instructions is executed against
the bytes right before 803E, to be exact in the function at address
00404E8F. This function generates a series of bytes which are compared later
on to the bytes AFTER 803E. If they match you are granted auth.

The auth. byte comarison is done in the following instruction:
00409797 |. F3:A7 REPE CMPS DWORD PTR ES:[EDI],DWORD PTR DS:[ESI] Anyone can
easily bypass this by modifying the values provided by the memory addresses,
to make them match.


Steps to access PGP Encrypted Disk (Passphrase) using a Backdoor type attack
============================================================================
    * Create a PGP disk 100K (to make stuff simpler)
    * Use a as username and 1 as passphrase for simplicity
    * Call your file pgpdisk.pgd
    * Now your disk will be created and mounted. Put a inside it
(secret.txt) then Unmount the disk (pgpdisk.pgd)
    * Make a Back-up copy call it pgpdisk_backup.pgd (You need this when you
want to access back the disk)
    * Now say you give that disk to someone and they changed the passphrase
on it. You can still access it if you follow these steps
    * To put a new passphrase on your disk Right click pgpdisk.pgd you see
PGP select Edit PGPdisk
    * You see a username, right click it and select change passphrase. Use
WHATEVER PASSPHRASE YOU WANT
    * After changing the passphrase the OLD passphrase SHOULD NOT work.
    * Open pgpdisk.pgd and pgpdisk_backup.pgd in HEX editor e.g Ultraedit
ONLY CHANGE WHERE YOU SEE A RED RECTANGULAR.
    * We start editing from the BOTTOM of the file at 80 3E.
    * Do some copy and past from the back-up file into pgpdisk.pgd
    * Follow the screen shots and replace indicated bits.
    * After your done save the file pgpdisk.pgd and double click on it. It
will ask for the passphrase. Type 1 yes your old pass
    * The disk will mount and you see the files in it.

 
// Full detail can be found here //
<> http://www.safehack.com/Advisory/pgp/PGPcrack.html
<> http://www.safehack.com/advisory/truecrypt/truecrypt.html



LESSON LEARNED, this advisory should be a wakeup call for other products.
Again as you see both commercial an OpenProject applications are affected by
this. This should be more then enough to kill the Open<>close project myth
and concentrate on secure coding and GOOD AUDIT.


Author: Adonis a.K.a NtWaK0, Abed
Date: 2006-05-08
C 2006 All rights reserved

_______________________________________________
Get your free port scan here: http://www.seifried.org/freescan2/

security mailing list
security@...ts.seifried.org
https://lists.seifried.org/mailman/listinfo/security

Powered by blists - more mailing lists