| lists.openwall.net | lists / announce owl-users owl-dev john-users john-dev passwdqc-users yescrypt popa3d-users / oss-security kernel-hardening musl sabotage tlsify passwords / crypt-dev xvendor / Bugtraq Full-Disclosure linux-kernel linux-netdev linux-ext4 linux-hardening linux-cve-announce PHC | |
|
Open Source and information security mailing list archives
| ||
|
Message-ID: <20111214133400.GA18565@localhost>
Date: Wed, 14 Dec 2011 21:34:00 +0800
From: Wu Fengguang <fengguang.wu@...el.com>
To: "linux-ext4@...r.kernel.org" <linux-ext4@...r.kernel.org>
Cc: Jan Kara <jack@...e.cz>, Li Shaohua <shaohua.li@...el.com>,
LKML <linux-kernel@...r.kernel.org>,
"linux-fsdevel@...r.kernel.org" <linux-fsdevel@...r.kernel.org>,
Theodore Ts'o <tytso@....edu>
Subject: ext4 data=writeback performs worse than data=ordered now
Hi,
Shaohua recently found that ext4 writeback mode could perform worse
than ordered mode in some cases. It may not be a big problem, however
we'd like to share some information on our findings.
I tested both 3.2 and 3.1 kernels on normal SATA disks and USB key.
The interesting thing is, data=writeback used to run a bit faster
than data=ordered, however situation get inverted presumably by the
IO-less dirty throttling.
The worst case happens for the USB key, where both old/new kernels
see ~10% worse performance for data=writeback.
wfg@bee /export/writeback% ./compare -g ext4 -c fs snb/JBOD*/*-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
ext4 ext4:wb
------------------------ ------------------------
216.50 -0.5% 215.50 snb/JBOD-4HDD-thresh=100M/ext4-1dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
210.34 -0.5% 209.36 snb/JBOD-4HDD-thresh=1G/ext4-10dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
218.92 -0.5% 217.85 snb/JBOD-4HDD-thresh=1G/ext4-1dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
218.03 -0.1% 217.72 snb/JBOD-4HDD-thresh=8G/ext4-10dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
221.19 -2.0% 216.82 snb/JBOD-4HDD-thresh=8G/ext4-1dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
1084.98 -0.7% 1077.26 TOTAL write_bw
wfg@bee /export/writeback% ./compare -g ext4 -c fs fat/*/*-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
ext4 ext4:wb
------------------------ ------------------------
46.87 -1.9% 45.96 fat/UKEY-HDD/ext4-100dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
57.40 -4.9% 54.61 fat/UKEY-HDD/ext4-10dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
62.13 -1.2% 61.41 fat/UKEY-HDD/ext4-1dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
2.46 -1.0% 2.44 fat/UKEY-thresh=100M/ext4-100dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
4.52 -4.3% 4.33 fat/UKEY-thresh=100M/ext4-10dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
6.20 -10.6% 5.54 fat/UKEY-thresh=100M/ext4-1dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
2.55 +8.7% 2.77 fat/fio/ext4-fio_fat_mmap_randwrite_4k-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
9.60 -4.0% 9.21 fat/fio/ext4-fio_fat_mmap_randwrite_64k-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
53.57 -3.6% 51.61 fat/fio/ext4-fio_fat_rates-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
49.16 -1.3% 48.51 fat/thresh=1000M/ext4-100dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
56.20 -1.4% 55.40 fat/thresh=1000M/ext4-10dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
57.86 -1.4% 57.07 fat/thresh=1000M/ext4-1dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
50.36 -3.2% 48.75 fat/thresh=1000M:990M/ext4-100dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
56.46 -1.4% 55.69 fat/thresh=1000M:990M/ext4-10dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
57.51 -0.9% 56.97 fat/thresh=1000M:990M/ext4-1dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
50.02 -0.8% 49.60 fat/thresh=1000M:999M/ext4-100dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
55.56 -1.3% 54.84 fat/thresh=1000M:999M/ext4-10dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
56.88 -0.6% 56.52 fat/thresh=1000M:999M/ext4-1dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
32.03 -3.3% 30.98 fat/thresh=100M/ext4-100dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
46.63 -2.5% 45.47 fat/thresh=100M/ext4-10dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
56.67 -2.3% 55.34 fat/thresh=100M/ext4-1dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
36.16 -0.9% 35.84 fat/thresh=10M/ext4-10dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
56.01 -0.1% 55.98 fat/thresh=10M/ext4-1dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
31.45 +0.2% 31.51 fat/thresh=1M/ext4-10dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
52.83 -2.3% 51.62 fat/thresh=1M/ext4-1dd-1-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
1047.06 -1.8% 1027.98 TOTAL write_bw
wfg@bee /export/writeback% ./compare -g ext4 -c fs fat/*/*-3.1.0+
ext4 ext4:wb
------------------------ ------------------------
45.91 +2.2% 46.90 fat/UKEY-HDD/ext4-100dd-1-3.1.0+
54.53 +7.4% 58.54 fat/UKEY-HDD/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
62.18 -3.8% 59.83 fat/UKEY-HDD/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
2.41 -10.7% 2.15 fat/UKEY-thresh=100M/ext4-100dd-1-3.1.0+
4.24 -3.0% 4.11 fat/UKEY-thresh=100M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
6.25 -11.6% 5.53 fat/UKEY-thresh=100M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
2.20 +0.6% 2.22 fat/fio/ext4-fio_fat_mmap_randwrite_4k-1-3.1.0+
8.76 -4.2% 8.40 fat/fio/ext4-fio_fat_mmap_randwrite_64k-1-3.1.0+
50.95 +0.4% 51.17 fat/fio/ext4-fio_fat_rates-1-3.1.0+
47.44 +4.1% 49.40 fat/thresh=1000M/ext4-100dd-1-3.1.0+
53.30 +4.3% 55.60 fat/thresh=1000M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
56.02 +0.8% 56.47 fat/thresh=1000M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
47.99 +1.3% 48.61 fat/thresh=1000M:990M/ext4-100dd-1-3.1.0+
52.82 +0.3% 53.00 fat/thresh=1000M:990M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
54.73 +1.9% 55.74 fat/thresh=1000M:990M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
47.91 -0.6% 47.62 fat/thresh=1000M:999M/ext4-100dd-1-3.1.0+
51.51 +3.0% 53.05 fat/thresh=1000M:999M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
52.88 +1.6% 53.71 fat/thresh=1000M:999M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
34.56 -2.3% 33.76 fat/thresh=100M/ext4-100dd-1-3.1.0+
46.44 -1.3% 45.86 fat/thresh=100M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
54.76 +3.5% 56.65 fat/thresh=100M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
37.43 +3.4% 38.69 fat/thresh=10M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
55.21 -0.5% 54.95 fat/thresh=10M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
40.36 -1.3% 39.83 fat/thresh=1M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
55.66 -0.1% 55.61 fat/thresh=1M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
1026.44 +1.1% 1037.40 TOTAL write_bw
Here are the comparison between kernels. As you can see, the ordered
mode is improved slightly by 2% w/ IO-less, while data=writeback sees
-0.9% drop.
wfg@bee /export/writeback% ./compare -g ext4- fat/*/*-3.1.0+ fat/*/*-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
3.1.0+ 3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
------------------------ ------------------------
45.91 +2.1% 46.87 fat/UKEY-HDD/ext4-100dd-1-3.1.0+
54.53 +5.3% 57.40 fat/UKEY-HDD/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
62.18 -0.1% 62.13 fat/UKEY-HDD/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
2.41 +2.1% 2.46 fat/UKEY-thresh=100M/ext4-100dd-1-3.1.0+
4.24 +6.6% 4.52 fat/UKEY-thresh=100M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
6.25 -0.9% 6.20 fat/UKEY-thresh=100M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
2.20 +15.6% 2.55 fat/fio/ext4-fio_fat_mmap_randwrite_4k-1-3.1.0+
8.76 +9.5% 9.60 fat/fio/ext4-fio_fat_mmap_randwrite_64k-1-3.1.0+
50.95 +5.1% 53.57 fat/fio/ext4-fio_fat_rates-1-3.1.0+
47.44 +3.6% 49.16 fat/thresh=1000M/ext4-100dd-1-3.1.0+
53.30 +5.4% 56.20 fat/thresh=1000M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
56.02 +3.3% 57.86 fat/thresh=1000M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
47.99 +4.9% 50.36 fat/thresh=1000M:990M/ext4-100dd-1-3.1.0+
52.82 +6.9% 56.46 fat/thresh=1000M:990M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
54.73 +5.1% 57.51 fat/thresh=1000M:990M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
47.91 +4.4% 50.02 fat/thresh=1000M:999M/ext4-100dd-1-3.1.0+
51.51 +7.9% 55.56 fat/thresh=1000M:999M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
52.88 +7.6% 56.88 fat/thresh=1000M:999M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
34.56 -7.3% 32.03 fat/thresh=100M/ext4-100dd-1-3.1.0+
46.44 +0.4% 46.63 fat/thresh=100M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
54.76 +3.5% 56.67 fat/thresh=100M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
37.43 -3.4% 36.16 fat/thresh=10M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
55.21 +1.5% 56.01 fat/thresh=10M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
40.36 -22.1% 31.45 fat/thresh=1M/ext4-10dd-1-3.1.0+
55.66 -5.1% 52.83 fat/thresh=1M/ext4-1dd-1-3.1.0+
1026.44 +2.0% 1047.06 TOTAL write_bw
wfg@bee /export/writeback% ./compare -g ext4:wb fat/*/*-3.1.0+ fat/*/*-3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
3.1.0+ 3.2.0-rc3-pause6+
------------------------ ------------------------
46.90 -2.0% 45.96 fat/UKEY-HDD/ext4:wb-100dd-1-3.1.0+
58.54 -6.7% 54.61 fat/UKEY-HDD/ext4:wb-10dd-1-3.1.0+
59.83 +2.7% 61.41 fat/UKEY-HDD/ext4:wb-1dd-1-3.1.0+
2.15 +13.3% 2.44 fat/UKEY-thresh=100M/ext4:wb-100dd-1-3.1.0+
4.11 +5.2% 4.33 fat/UKEY-thresh=100M/ext4:wb-10dd-1-3.1.0+
5.53 +0.2% 5.54 fat/UKEY-thresh=100M/ext4:wb-1dd-1-3.1.0+
2.22 +24.8% 2.77 fat/fio/ext4:wb-fio_fat_mmap_randwrite_4k-1-3.1.0+
8.40 +9.6% 9.21 fat/fio/ext4:wb-fio_fat_mmap_randwrite_64k-1-3.1.0+
51.17 +0.9% 51.61 fat/fio/ext4:wb-fio_fat_rates-1-3.1.0+
49.40 -1.8% 48.51 fat/thresh=1000M/ext4:wb-100dd-1-3.1.0+
55.60 -0.3% 55.40 fat/thresh=1000M/ext4:wb-10dd-1-3.1.0+
56.47 +1.1% 57.07 fat/thresh=1000M/ext4:wb-1dd-1-3.1.0+
48.61 +0.3% 48.75 fat/thresh=1000M:990M/ext4:wb-100dd-1-3.1.0+
53.00 +5.1% 55.69 fat/thresh=1000M:990M/ext4:wb-10dd-1-3.1.0+
55.74 +2.2% 56.97 fat/thresh=1000M:990M/ext4:wb-1dd-1-3.1.0+
47.62 +4.2% 49.60 fat/thresh=1000M:999M/ext4:wb-100dd-1-3.1.0+
53.05 +3.4% 54.84 fat/thresh=1000M:999M/ext4:wb-10dd-1-3.1.0+
53.71 +5.2% 56.52 fat/thresh=1000M:999M/ext4:wb-1dd-1-3.1.0+
33.76 -8.3% 30.98 fat/thresh=100M/ext4:wb-100dd-1-3.1.0+
45.86 -0.8% 45.47 fat/thresh=100M/ext4:wb-10dd-1-3.1.0+
56.65 -2.3% 55.34 fat/thresh=100M/ext4:wb-1dd-1-3.1.0+
38.69 -7.4% 35.84 fat/thresh=10M/ext4:wb-10dd-1-3.1.0+
54.95 +1.9% 55.98 fat/thresh=10M/ext4:wb-1dd-1-3.1.0+
39.83 -20.9% 31.51 fat/thresh=1M/ext4:wb-10dd-1-3.1.0+
55.61 -7.2% 51.62 fat/thresh=1M/ext4:wb-1dd-1-3.1.0+
1037.40 -0.9% 1027.98 TOTAL write_bw
Thanks,
Fengguang
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-ext4" in
the body of a message to majordomo@...r.kernel.org
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Powered by blists - more mailing lists