Date:	Tue, 19 Jan 2016 18:10:40 -0200
From:	Gustavo Padovan <gustavo@...ovan.org>
To:	Greg Kroah-Hartman <gregkh@...uxfoundation.org>,
	linux-kernel@...r.kernel.org, devel@...verdev.osuosl.org,
	dri-devel@...ts.freedesktop.org, daniels@...labora.com,
	Arve Hjønnevåg <arve@...roid.com>,
	Riley Andrews <riandrews@...roid.com>,
	Rob Clark <robdclark@...il.com>,
	Greg Hackmann <ghackmann@...gle.com>,
	John Harrison <John.C.Harrison@...el.com>,
	Gustavo Padovan <gustavo.padovan@...labora.co.uk>
Subject: Re: [RFC 00/29] De-stage android's sync framework

2016-01-19 Daniel Vetter <daniel@...ll.ch>:

> On Fri, Jan 15, 2016 at 12:55:10PM -0200, Gustavo Padovan wrote:
> > From: Gustavo Padovan <gustavo.padovan@...labora.co.uk>
> > 
> > This patch series de-stage the sync framework, and in order to accomplish that
> > a bunch of cleanups/improvements on the sync and fence were made.
> > 
> > The sync framework contained some abstractions around struct fence and those
> > were removed in the de-staging process among other changes:
> > 
> > Userspace visible changes
> > -------------------------
> > 
> >  * The sw_sync file was moved from /dev/sw_sync to <debugfs>/sync/sw_sync. No
> >  other change.
> > 
> > Kernel API changes
> > ------------------
> > 
> >  * struct sync_timeline is now struct fence_timeline
> >  * sync_timeline_ops is now fence_timeline_ops and they now carry struct
> >  fence as parameter instead of struct sync_pt
> >  * a .cleanup() fence op was added to allow sync_fence to run a cleanup when
> >  the fence_timeline is destroyed
> >  * added fence_add_used_data() to pass a private point to struct fence. This
> >  pointer is sent back on the .cleanup op.
> >  * The sync timeline function were moved to be fence_timeline functions:
> > 	 - sync_timeline_create()	-> fence_timeline_create()
> > 	 - sync_timeline_get()		-> fence_timeline_get()
> > 	 - sync_timeline_put()		-> fence_timeline_put()
> > 	 - sync_timeline_destroy()	-> fence_timeline_destroy()
> > 	 - sync_timeline_signal()	-> fence_timeline_signal()
> > 
> >   * sync_pt_create() was replaced be fence_create_on_timeline()
> > 
> > Internal changes
> > ----------------
> > 
> >  * fence_timeline_ops was removed in favor of direct use fence_ops
> >  * fence default functions were created for fence_ops
> >  * removed structs sync_pt, sw_sync_timeline and sw_sync_pt
> 
> Bunch of fairly random comments all over:
> 
> - include/uapi/linux/sw_sync.h imo should be dropped, it's just a private
>   debugfs interface between fence fds and the testsuite. Since the plan is
>   to have the testcases integrated into the kernel tree too we don't need
>   a public header.
> 
> - similar for include/linux/sw_sync.h Imo that should all be moved into
>   sync_debug.c. Same for sw_sync.c, that should all land in sync_debug
>   imo, and made optional with a Kconfig option. At least we should reuse
>   CONFIG_DEBUGFS.
> 
> - fence_context and fence_timeline are really the same. timeline has some
>   super-basic support for doing sw-only fence timelines, but imo that's
>   not really worth keeping (and if so better to keep seperate in a
>   sw-fence.c or similar, like seqno-fence.c). The other main thing
>   timeline provides is support to clean up fences on a timeline. And imo
>   that cleanup should be done by the core fence support, not by the add-on
>   stuff.
> 
> Interlude about fence cleanup on driver unload:
> 
> Working drivers imo should never call timeline_destroy when there's still
> an unsignalled fence around for that timeline/context. That just means
> they're broken and failed to clean up all the pending work. So the problem
> really is only what to do with fences where the driver disappeared, and
> for that we essentially need a fence_revoke() function (which could be
> called internally from timeline_free). So here's what I think
> timeline_free should do:
> 
> for_each_fence_on_timel() {
> 	WARN_ON(!fence_is_signalled());
> 
> 	fence_revoke(fence);
> }
> 
> Implementing fence_revoke is a bit tricky since we need to make sure the
> memory contained ->ops and similar stuff doesn't disappear. Simplest
> option might be to grab a temporary reference (using
> kref_get_unless_zero), and then exchange ->ops with one that has only a
> release function. We don't need anything else as long as all fence_*
> functions the kernel might call check for signalling correctly first
> (fence_wait is broken at least).
> 
> Or we just give up (for now) and declare module unload as slightly racy.
> dma-buf is similar. An intermediate option might be to at least add a
> THIS_MODULE reference to each fence (but that's a bit expensive ...).
> 
> - back to timeline vs. context: I have no idea how to best clean up this
>   mess, but least painful option long-term is probably to switch over all
>   current users of fence_context_alloc to timelines and remove the plain
>   context interface.
> 
> - Imo the interface in include/linux/sync.h is duplicating too much of
>   fence.h. I think the only bits we need are the refcounting, creating,
>   fd-install and that's it. Plus a macro to loop over all the fences in a
>   sync_fence. With that drivers will only ever deal with a pile of
>   struct fence, making implicit fencing (using the fence list in dma-buf)
>   and explicit fencing (using the fence list in sync_fence) much more
>   similar.
> 
>   And we can easily do that since no internal users ;-)
> 
> - get_timeline_name and get_driver_name are imo too much indirection, just
>   add ->(drv_)name field to each of these.

I don't think is a good idea to change that now as there are other fence
users in the kernel using get_timeline_name and get_driver_name. What I
propose is try get rid of this when moving ops from fences to
fence_timeline.

	Gustavo

Powered by blists - more mailing lists