Message-ID: <87blgag4an.derkling@matbug.net>
Date:   Fri, 06 Nov 2020 11:36:48 +0100
From:   Patrick Bellasi <patrick.bellasi@...bug.net>
To:     Yun Hsiang <hsiang023167@...il.com>
Cc:     dietmar.eggemann@....com, peterz@...radead.org,
        linux-kernel@...r.kernel.org, qais.yousef@....com,
        kernel test robot <lkp@...el.com>
Subject: Re: [PATCH v5 1/1] sched/uclamp: add SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_RESET
 flag to reset uclamp


Hi Yun,
thanks for keep improving this.

I'm replying here but still considering all other reviewers comments.

Best,
Patrick

On Tue, Nov 03, 2020 at 03:37:56 +0100, Yun Hsiang <hsiang023167@...il.com> wrote...

> If the user wants to stop controlling uclamp and let the task inherit
> the value from the group, we need a method to reset.
>
> Add SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_RESET flag to allow the user to reset uclamp via
> sched_setattr syscall.
>
> The policy is
> _CLAMP_RESET                           => reset both min and max
> _CLAMP_RESET | _CLAMP_MIN              => reset min value
> _CLAMP_RESET | _CLAMP_MAX              => reset max value
> _CLAMP_RESET | _CLAMP_MIN | _CLAMP_MAX => reset both min and max

This documentation should be added to the uapi header and, most
importantly, in:
  include/uapi/linux/sched/types.h
where the documentation for struct sched_attr is provided.


> Signed-off-by: Yun Hsiang <hsiang023167@...il.com>
> Reported-by: kernel test robot <lkp@...el.com>
> ---
>  include/uapi/linux/sched.h |  7 +++--
>  kernel/sched/core.c        | 59 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++----------
>  2 files changed, 49 insertions(+), 17 deletions(-)
>
> diff --git a/include/uapi/linux/sched.h b/include/uapi/linux/sched.h
> index 3bac0a8ceab2..6c823ddb1a1e 100644
> --- a/include/uapi/linux/sched.h
> +++ b/include/uapi/linux/sched.h
> @@ -132,17 +132,20 @@ struct clone_args {
>  #define SCHED_FLAG_KEEP_PARAMS		0x10
>  #define SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MIN	0x20
>  #define SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MAX	0x40
> +#define SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_RESET	0x80
>  
>  #define SCHED_FLAG_KEEP_ALL	(SCHED_FLAG_KEEP_POLICY | \
>  				 SCHED_FLAG_KEEP_PARAMS)
>  

(Related to the following discussion point)
What about adding in a comment here to call out that the following
definitions are "internal only"?
Moreover, we could probably wrap the following two define within an
#ifdef __KERNEL__/#endif block


Something like:

+ /*
+ * The following definitions are internal only, do not use them to set
+ * set_{set,get}attr() params. Use instead a valid combination of the
+ * flags defined above.
+ */
+ #ifdef __KERNEL__

>  #define SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP	(SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MIN | \
> -				 SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MAX)
> +				 SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MAX | \
> +				 SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_RESET)

We need the _RESET flag only here (not below), since this is a UCLAMP
feature and it's worth/useful to have a single "all uclamp flags"
definition...

>  #define SCHED_FLAG_ALL	(SCHED_FLAG_RESET_ON_FORK	| \
>  			 SCHED_FLAG_RECLAIM		| \
>  			 SCHED_FLAG_DL_OVERRUN		| \
>  			 SCHED_FLAG_KEEP_ALL		| \
> -			 SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP)
> +			 SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP		| \
> +			 SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_RESET)

... i.e., you can drop the chunk above.

+ #endif /* __KERNEL__ */

Regarding Qais comment, I had the same Dietmar's thought: I doubt there
are apps using _FLAGS_ALL from userspace. For DL tasks, since they
cannot fork, it makes no sense to specify, for example
_RESET_ON_FORK|_RECLAIM. For CFS/RT tasks, where UCLAMP is supported, it
makes no sense to specify DL flags.

It's true however that having this def here when it's supposed to be
used only internally, can be kind of "confusing", but it's also useful
to keep the definition aligned with the flags defined above.
The ifdef wrapping proposed above should make this even more explicit.

Perhaps we can also better call this out also with an additional note
right after:

  https://elixir.bootlin.com/linux/v5.9.6/source/include/uapi/linux/sched/types.h#L43

In that file, I believe the "Task Utilization Attributes" section can
also be improved by adding a description of the _UCLAMP flags semantics.


>  #endif /* _UAPI_LINUX_SCHED_H */
> diff --git a/kernel/sched/core.c b/kernel/sched/core.c
> index 8160ab5263f8..6ae463b64834 100644
> --- a/kernel/sched/core.c
> +++ b/kernel/sched/core.c
> @@ -1004,7 +1004,7 @@ unsigned int uclamp_rq_max_value(struct rq *rq, enum uclamp_id clamp_id,
>  	return uclamp_idle_value(rq, clamp_id, clamp_value);
>  }
>  
> -static void __uclamp_update_util_min_rt_default(struct task_struct *p)
> +static inline void __uclamp_update_util_min_rt_default(struct task_struct *p)
>  {

Again, IMO, this is _not_ an unrelated change at all. Actually, I still
would like to do one step more and inline this function in the _only
place_ where it's used. Qais arguments for not doing that where [1]:

  Updating the default rt value is done from different contexts. Hence
  it is important to document the rules under which this update must
  happen and ensure the update happens through a common path.

I don't see why these arguments are not satisfied when we inline, e.g.

---8<---
diff --git a/kernel/sched/core.c b/kernel/sched/core.c
index d2003a7d5ab5..369074154e1d 100644
--- a/kernel/sched/core.c
+++ b/kernel/sched/core.c
@@ -1004,25 +1004,9 @@ unsigned int uclamp_rq_max_value(struct rq *rq, enum uclamp_id clamp_id,
        return uclamp_idle_value(rq, clamp_id, clamp_value);
 }
 
-static void __uclamp_update_util_min_rt_default(struct task_struct *p)
-{
-       unsigned int default_util_min;
-       struct uclamp_se *uc_se;
-
-       lockdep_assert_held(&p->pi_lock);
-
-       uc_se = &p->uclamp_req[UCLAMP_MIN];
-
-       /* Only sync if user didn't override the default */
-       if (uc_se->user_defined)
-               return;
-
-       default_util_min = sysctl_sched_uclamp_util_min_rt_default;
-       uclamp_se_set(uc_se, default_util_min, false);
-}
-
 static void uclamp_update_util_min_rt_default(struct task_struct *p)
 {
+       struct uclamp_se *uc_se = &p->uclamp_req[UCLAMP_MIN];
        struct rq_flags rf;
        struct rq *rq;
 
@@ -1031,7 +1015,11 @@ static void uclamp_update_util_min_rt_default(struct task_struct *p)
 
        /* Protect updates to p->uclamp_* */
        rq = task_rq_lock(p, &rf);
-       __uclamp_update_util_min_rt_default(p);
+
+       /* Only sync if user didn't override the default */
+       if (!uc_se->user_defined)
+               uclamp_se_set(uc_se, sysctl_sched_uclamp_util_min_rt_default, false);
+
        task_rq_unlock(rq, p, &rf);
 }
---8<---

[1] https://lore.kernel.org/lkml/20201028182946.6qfmt7q35ewrjjua@e107158-lin/

>  	unsigned int default_util_min;
>  	struct uclamp_se *uc_se;
> @@ -1413,8 +1413,14 @@ int sysctl_sched_uclamp_handler(struct ctl_table *table, int write,
>  static int uclamp_validate(struct task_struct *p,
>  			   const struct sched_attr *attr)
>  {
> -	unsigned int lower_bound = p->uclamp_req[UCLAMP_MIN].value;
> -	unsigned int upper_bound = p->uclamp_req[UCLAMP_MAX].value;
> +	unsigned int lower_bound, upper_bound;
> +
> +	/* Do not check uclamp attributes values in reset case. */
> +	if (attr->sched_flags & SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_RESET)
> +		return 0;
> +
> +	lower_bound = p->uclamp_req[UCLAMP_MIN].value;
> +	upper_bound = p->uclamp_req[UCLAMP_MAX].value;
>  
>  	if (attr->sched_flags & SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MIN)
>  		lower_bound = attr->sched_util_min;
> @@ -1438,20 +1444,43 @@ static int uclamp_validate(struct task_struct *p,
>  	return 0;
>  }
>  
> +static int uclamp_reset(enum uclamp_id clamp_id, unsigned long flags)
> +{
> +	/* No _UCLAMP_RESET flag set: do not reset */

              ^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Maybe better using the full flag name for all these?

> +	if (!(flags & SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_RESET))
> +		return false;
> +
> +	/* Only _UCLAMP_RESET flag set: reset both clamps */
> +	if (!(flags & (SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MIN | SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MAX)))
> +		return true;
> +
> +	/* Both _UCLAMP_RESET and _UCLAMP_MIN flags are set: reset only min */
> +	if ((flags & SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MIN) && clamp_id == UCLAMP_MIN)
> +		return true;
> +
> +	/* Both _UCLAMP_RESET and _UCLAMP_MAX flags are set: reset only max */
> +	if ((flags & SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MAX) && clamp_id == UCLAMP_MAX)
> +		return true;
> +
> +	return false;

I was suggesting maybe we need READ_ONCE() in the if above but did not
addressed previous Dietmar's question [2] on why.

The function above has a correct semantics only when the ordering of the
if statement is strictly observed.

Now, since we don't have any data dependency on the multiple if cases,
are we sure an overzealous compiler will never come up with some
"optimized reordering" of the checks required?

IOW, if the compiler could scramble the checks on an optimization, we
would get a wrong semantics which is also very difficult do debug.
Hence the idea to use READ_ONCE, to both tell the compiler to not
even attempt reordering those checks and also to better document the
code about the importance of the ordering on those checks.

Is now more clear? Does that makes sense?

[2] https://lore.kernel.org/lkml/c59f7c85-59a2-488b-ce51-b3abee506dac@arm.com/

> +}
> +
>  static void __setscheduler_uclamp(struct task_struct *p,
>  				  const struct sched_attr *attr)
>  {
>  	enum uclamp_id clamp_id;
>  
>  	/*
> -	 * On scheduling class change, reset to default clamps for tasks
> -	 * without a task-specific value.
> +	 * Reset to default clamps on forced _UCLAMP_RESET (always) and
> +	 * for tasks without a task-specific value (on scheduling class change).
>  	 */
>  	for_each_clamp_id(clamp_id) {
> +		unsigned int clamp_value;
>  		struct uclamp_se *uc_se = &p->uclamp_req[clamp_id];
>  
>  		/* Keep using defined clamps across class changes */
> -		if (uc_se->user_defined)
> +		if (!uclamp_reset(clamp_id, attr->sched_flags) &&
> +				uc_se->user_defined)
>  			continue;
>  
>  		/*
> @@ -1459,24 +1488,24 @@ static void __setscheduler_uclamp(struct task_struct *p,
>  		 * at runtime.
>  		 */
>  		if (unlikely(rt_task(p) && clamp_id == UCLAMP_MIN))
> -			__uclamp_update_util_min_rt_default(p);
> +			clamp_value = sysctl_sched_uclamp_util_min_rt_default;
>  		else
> -			uclamp_se_set(uc_se, uclamp_none(clamp_id), false);
> +			clamp_value = uclamp_none(clamp_id);
>  
> +		uclamp_se_set(uc_se, clamp_value, false);
>  	}
>  
> -	if (likely(!(attr->sched_flags & SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP)))
> +	if (likely(!(attr->sched_flags && SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP)) ||
> +		attr->sched_flags & SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_RESET)
>  		return;

Parenthesis required for multi-line is statements.

Following chucks not required.

> -	if (attr->sched_flags & SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MIN) {
> +	if (attr->sched_flags & SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MIN)
>  		uclamp_se_set(&p->uclamp_req[UCLAMP_MIN],
> -			      attr->sched_util_min, true);
> -	}
> +				attr->sched_util_min, true);
>  
> -	if (attr->sched_flags & SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MAX) {
> +	if (attr->sched_flags & SCHED_FLAG_UTIL_CLAMP_MAX)
>  		uclamp_se_set(&p->uclamp_req[UCLAMP_MAX],
> -			      attr->sched_util_max, true);
> -	}
> +				attr->sched_util_max, true);
>  }
>  
>  static void uclamp_fork(struct task_struct *p)

Powered by blists - more mailing lists