[<prev] [next>] [<thread-prev] [day] [month] [year] [list]
Message-ID: <202203151554.mlaV8elU-lkp@intel.com>
Date: Tue, 15 Mar 2022 15:56:28 +0800
From: kernel test robot <lkp@...el.com>
To: Haowen Bai <baihaowen@...zu.com>, hca@...ux.ibm.com,
gor@...ux.ibm.com, agordeev@...ux.ibm.com
Cc: kbuild-all@...ts.01.org, linux-s390@...r.kernel.org,
linux-kernel@...r.kernel.org, Haowen Bai <baihaowen@...zu.com>
Subject: Re: [PATCH] s390/tape: Use bitwise instead of arithmetic operator
for flags
Hi Haowen,
Thank you for the patch! Perhaps something to improve:
[auto build test WARNING on s390/features]
[also build test WARNING on v5.17-rc8 next-20220310]
[If your patch is applied to the wrong git tree, kindly drop us a note.
And when submitting patch, we suggest to use '--base' as documented in
https://git-scm.com/docs/git-format-patch]
url: https://github.com/0day-ci/linux/commits/Haowen-Bai/s390-tape-Use-bitwise-instead-of-arithmetic-operator-for-flags/20220315-102644
base: https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/s390/linux.git features
config: s390-defconfig (https://download.01.org/0day-ci/archive/20220315/202203151554.mlaV8elU-lkp@intel.com/config)
compiler: s390-linux-gcc (GCC) 11.2.0
reproduce (this is a W=1 build):
wget https://raw.githubusercontent.com/intel/lkp-tests/master/sbin/make.cross -O ~/bin/make.cross
chmod +x ~/bin/make.cross
# https://github.com/0day-ci/linux/commit/c549742b07b69efbf79208adc82f8a5650cc7311
git remote add linux-review https://github.com/0day-ci/linux
git fetch --no-tags linux-review Haowen-Bai/s390-tape-Use-bitwise-instead-of-arithmetic-operator-for-flags/20220315-102644
git checkout c549742b07b69efbf79208adc82f8a5650cc7311
# save the config file to linux build tree
mkdir build_dir
COMPILER_INSTALL_PATH=$HOME/0day COMPILER=gcc-11.2.0 make.cross O=build_dir ARCH=s390 SHELL=/bin/bash drivers/s390/char/
If you fix the issue, kindly add following tag as appropriate
Reported-by: kernel test robot <lkp@...el.com>
All warnings (new ones prefixed by >>):
drivers/s390/char/tape_34xx.c: In function 'tape_34xx_unit_check':
>> drivers/s390/char/tape_34xx.c:357:26: warning: suggest parentheses around comparison in operand of '|' [-Wparentheses]
357 | sense[0] == SENSE_EQUIPMENT_CHECK | SENSE_DEFERRED_UNIT_CHECK
drivers/s390/char/tape_34xx.c:360:26: warning: suggest parentheses around comparison in operand of '|' [-Wparentheses]
360 | sense[1] == SENSE_BEGINNING_OF_TAPE | SENSE_WRITE_MODE
vim +357 drivers/s390/char/tape_34xx.c
310
311 /*
312 * This function analyses the tape's sense-data in case of a unit-check.
313 * If possible, it tries to recover from the error. Else the user is
314 * informed about the problem.
315 */
316 static int
317 tape_34xx_unit_check(struct tape_device *device, struct tape_request *request,
318 struct irb *irb)
319 {
320 int inhibit_cu_recovery;
321 __u8* sense;
322
323 inhibit_cu_recovery = (*device->modeset_byte & 0x80) ? 1 : 0;
324 sense = irb->ecw;
325
326 if (
327 sense[0] & SENSE_COMMAND_REJECT &&
328 sense[1] & SENSE_WRITE_PROTECT
329 ) {
330 if (
331 request->op == TO_DSE ||
332 request->op == TO_WRI ||
333 request->op == TO_WTM
334 ) {
335 /* medium is write protected */
336 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EACCES);
337 } else {
338 return tape_34xx_erp_bug(device, request, irb, -3);
339 }
340 }
341
342 /*
343 * Special cases for various tape-states when reaching
344 * end of recorded area
345 *
346 * FIXME: Maybe a special case of the special case:
347 * sense[0] == SENSE_EQUIPMENT_CHECK &&
348 * sense[1] == SENSE_DRIVE_ONLINE &&
349 * sense[3] == 0x47 (Volume Fenced)
350 *
351 * This was caused by continued FSF or FSR after an
352 * 'End Of Data'.
353 */
354 if ((
355 sense[0] == SENSE_DATA_CHECK ||
356 sense[0] == SENSE_EQUIPMENT_CHECK ||
> 357 sense[0] == SENSE_EQUIPMENT_CHECK | SENSE_DEFERRED_UNIT_CHECK
358 ) && (
359 sense[1] == SENSE_DRIVE_ONLINE ||
360 sense[1] == SENSE_BEGINNING_OF_TAPE | SENSE_WRITE_MODE
361 )) {
362 switch (request->op) {
363 /*
364 * sense[0] == SENSE_DATA_CHECK &&
365 * sense[1] == SENSE_DRIVE_ONLINE
366 * sense[3] == 0x36 (End Of Data)
367 *
368 * Further seeks might return a 'Volume Fenced'.
369 */
370 case TO_FSF:
371 case TO_FSB:
372 /* Trying to seek beyond end of recorded area */
373 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -ENOSPC);
374 case TO_BSB:
375 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
376
377 /*
378 * sense[0] == SENSE_DATA_CHECK &&
379 * sense[1] == SENSE_DRIVE_ONLINE &&
380 * sense[3] == 0x36 (End Of Data)
381 */
382 case TO_LBL:
383 /* Block could not be located. */
384 tape_34xx_delete_sbid_from(device, 0);
385 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
386
387 case TO_RFO:
388 /* Read beyond end of recorded area -> 0 bytes read */
389 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, 0);
390
391 /*
392 * sense[0] == SENSE_EQUIPMENT_CHECK &&
393 * sense[1] == SENSE_DRIVE_ONLINE &&
394 * sense[3] == 0x38 (Physical End Of Volume)
395 */
396 case TO_WRI:
397 /* Writing at physical end of volume */
398 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -ENOSPC);
399 default:
400 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, 0);
401 }
402 }
403
404 /* Sensing special bits */
405 if (sense[0] & SENSE_BUS_OUT_CHECK)
406 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
407
408 if (sense[0] & SENSE_DATA_CHECK) {
409 /*
410 * hardware failure, damaged tape or improper
411 * operating conditions
412 */
413 switch (sense[3]) {
414 case 0x23:
415 /* a read data check occurred */
416 if ((sense[2] & SENSE_TAPE_SYNC_MODE) ||
417 inhibit_cu_recovery)
418 // data check is not permanent, may be
419 // recovered. We always use async-mode with
420 // cu-recovery, so this should *never* happen.
421 return tape_34xx_erp_bug(device, request,
422 irb, -4);
423
424 /* data check is permanent, CU recovery has failed */
425 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "A read error occurred "
426 "that cannot be recovered\n");
427 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
428 case 0x25:
429 // a write data check occurred
430 if ((sense[2] & SENSE_TAPE_SYNC_MODE) ||
431 inhibit_cu_recovery)
432 // data check is not permanent, may be
433 // recovered. We always use async-mode with
434 // cu-recovery, so this should *never* happen.
435 return tape_34xx_erp_bug(device, request,
436 irb, -5);
437
438 // data check is permanent, cu-recovery has failed
439 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "A write error on the "
440 "tape cannot be recovered\n");
441 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
442 case 0x26:
443 /* Data Check (read opposite) occurred. */
444 return tape_34xx_erp_read_opposite(device, request);
445 case 0x28:
446 /* ID-Mark at tape start couldn't be written */
447 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "Writing the ID-mark "
448 "failed\n");
449 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
450 case 0x31:
451 /* Tape void. Tried to read beyond end of device. */
452 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "Reading the tape beyond"
453 " the end of the recorded area failed\n");
454 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -ENOSPC);
455 case 0x41:
456 /* Record sequence error. */
457 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape contains an "
458 "incorrect block ID sequence\n");
459 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
460 default:
461 /* all data checks for 3480 should result in one of
462 * the above erpa-codes. For 3490, other data-check
463 * conditions do exist. */
464 if (device->cdev->id.driver_info == tape_3480)
465 return tape_34xx_erp_bug(device, request,
466 irb, -6);
467 }
468 }
469
470 if (sense[0] & SENSE_OVERRUN)
471 return tape_34xx_erp_overrun(device, request, irb);
472
473 if (sense[1] & SENSE_RECORD_SEQUENCE_ERR)
474 return tape_34xx_erp_sequence(device, request, irb);
475
476 /* Sensing erpa codes */
477 switch (sense[3]) {
478 case 0x00:
479 /* Unit check with erpa code 0. Report and ignore. */
480 return TAPE_IO_SUCCESS;
481 case 0x21:
482 /*
483 * Data streaming not operational. CU will switch to
484 * interlock mode. Reissue the command.
485 */
486 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
487 case 0x22:
488 /*
489 * Path equipment check. Might be drive adapter error, buffer
490 * error on the lower interface, internal path not usable,
491 * or error during cartridge load.
492 */
493 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "A path equipment check occurred"
494 " for the tape device\n");
495 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
496 case 0x24:
497 /*
498 * Load display check. Load display was command was issued,
499 * but the drive is displaying a drive check message. Can
500 * be threated as "device end".
501 */
502 return tape_34xx_erp_succeeded(request);
503 case 0x27:
504 /*
505 * Command reject. May indicate illegal channel program or
506 * buffer over/underrun. Since all channel programs are
507 * issued by this driver and ought be correct, we assume a
508 * over/underrun situation and retry the channel program.
509 */
510 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
511 case 0x29:
512 /*
513 * Function incompatible. Either the tape is idrc compressed
514 * but the hardware isn't capable to do idrc, or a perform
515 * subsystem func is issued and the CU is not on-line.
516 */
517 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
518 case 0x2a:
519 /*
520 * Unsolicited environmental data. An internal counter
521 * overflows, we can ignore this and reissue the cmd.
522 */
523 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
524 case 0x2b:
525 /*
526 * Environmental data present. Indicates either unload
527 * completed ok or read buffered log command completed ok.
528 */
529 if (request->op == TO_RUN) {
530 /* Rewind unload completed ok. */
531 tape_med_state_set(device, MS_UNLOADED);
532 return tape_34xx_erp_succeeded(request);
533 }
534 /* tape_34xx doesn't use read buffered log commands. */
535 return tape_34xx_erp_bug(device, request, irb, sense[3]);
536 case 0x2c:
537 /*
538 * Permanent equipment check. CU has tried recovery, but
539 * did not succeed.
540 */
541 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
542 case 0x2d:
543 /* Data security erase failure. */
544 if (request->op == TO_DSE)
545 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
546 /* Data security erase failure, but no such command issued. */
547 return tape_34xx_erp_bug(device, request, irb, sense[3]);
548 case 0x2e:
549 /*
550 * Not capable. This indicates either that the drive fails
551 * reading the format id mark or that that format specified
552 * is not supported by the drive.
553 */
554 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape unit cannot process "
555 "the tape format\n");
556 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EMEDIUMTYPE);
557 case 0x30:
558 /* The medium is write protected. */
559 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape medium is write-"
560 "protected\n");
561 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EACCES);
562 case 0x32:
563 // Tension loss. We cannot recover this, it's an I/O error.
564 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape does not have the "
565 "required tape tension\n");
566 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
567 case 0x33:
568 /*
569 * Load Failure. The cartridge was not inserted correctly or
570 * the tape is not threaded correctly.
571 */
572 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape unit failed to load"
573 " the cartridge\n");
574 tape_34xx_delete_sbid_from(device, 0);
575 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
576 case 0x34:
577 /*
578 * Unload failure. The drive cannot maintain tape tension
579 * and control tape movement during an unload operation.
580 */
581 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "Automatic unloading of the tape"
582 " cartridge failed\n");
583 if (request->op == TO_RUN)
584 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
585 return tape_34xx_erp_bug(device, request, irb, sense[3]);
586 case 0x35:
587 /*
588 * Drive equipment check. One of the following:
589 * - cu cannot recover from a drive detected error
590 * - a check code message is shown on drive display
591 * - the cartridge loader does not respond correctly
592 * - a failure occurs during an index, load, or unload cycle
593 */
594 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "An equipment check has occurred"
595 " on the tape unit\n");
596 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
597 case 0x36:
598 if (device->cdev->id.driver_info == tape_3490)
599 /* End of data. */
600 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
601 /* This erpa is reserved for 3480 */
602 return tape_34xx_erp_bug(device, request, irb, sense[3]);
603 case 0x37:
604 /*
605 * Tape length error. The tape is shorter than reported in
606 * the beginning-of-tape data.
607 */
608 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape information states an"
609 " incorrect length\n");
610 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
611 case 0x38:
612 /*
613 * Physical end of tape. A read/write operation reached
614 * the physical end of tape.
615 */
616 if (request->op==TO_WRI ||
617 request->op==TO_DSE ||
618 request->op==TO_WTM)
619 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -ENOSPC);
620 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
621 case 0x39:
622 /* Backward at Beginning of tape. */
623 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
624 case 0x3a:
625 /* Drive switched to not ready. */
626 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape unit is not ready\n");
627 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
628 case 0x3b:
629 /* Manual rewind or unload. This causes an I/O error. */
630 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape medium has been "
631 "rewound or unloaded manually\n");
632 tape_34xx_delete_sbid_from(device, 0);
633 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
634 case 0x42:
635 /*
636 * Degraded mode. A condition that can cause degraded
637 * performance is detected.
638 */
639 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape subsystem is running "
640 "in degraded mode\n");
641 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
642 case 0x43:
643 /* Drive not ready. */
644 tape_34xx_delete_sbid_from(device, 0);
645 tape_med_state_set(device, MS_UNLOADED);
646 /* Some commands commands are successful even in this case */
647 if (sense[1] & SENSE_DRIVE_ONLINE) {
648 switch(request->op) {
649 case TO_ASSIGN:
650 case TO_UNASSIGN:
651 case TO_DIS:
652 case TO_NOP:
653 return tape_34xx_done(request);
654 break;
655 default:
656 break;
657 }
658 }
659 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -ENOMEDIUM);
660 case 0x44:
661 /* Locate Block unsuccessful. */
662 if (request->op != TO_BLOCK && request->op != TO_LBL)
663 /* No locate block was issued. */
664 return tape_34xx_erp_bug(device, request,
665 irb, sense[3]);
666 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
667 case 0x45:
668 /* The drive is assigned to a different channel path. */
669 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape unit is already "
670 "assigned\n");
671 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
672 case 0x46:
673 /*
674 * Drive not on-line. Drive may be switched offline,
675 * the power supply may be switched off or
676 * the drive address may not be set correctly.
677 */
678 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape unit is not online\n");
679 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
680 case 0x47:
681 /* Volume fenced. CU reports volume integrity is lost. */
682 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The control unit has fenced "
683 "access to the tape volume\n");
684 tape_34xx_delete_sbid_from(device, 0);
685 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
686 case 0x48:
687 /* Log sense data and retry request. */
688 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
689 case 0x49:
690 /* Bus out check. A parity check error on the bus was found. */
691 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "A parity error occurred on the "
692 "tape bus\n");
693 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
694 case 0x4a:
695 /* Control unit erp failed. */
696 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "I/O error recovery failed on "
697 "the tape control unit\n");
698 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
699 case 0x4b:
700 /*
701 * CU and drive incompatible. The drive requests micro-program
702 * patches, which are not available on the CU.
703 */
704 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape unit requires a "
705 "firmware update\n");
706 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
707 case 0x4c:
708 /*
709 * Recovered Check-One failure. Cu develops a hardware error,
710 * but is able to recover.
711 */
712 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
713 case 0x4d:
714 if (device->cdev->id.driver_info == tape_3490)
715 /*
716 * Resetting event received. Since the driver does
717 * not support resetting event recovery (which has to
718 * be handled by the I/O Layer), retry our command.
719 */
720 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
721 /* This erpa is reserved for 3480. */
722 return tape_34xx_erp_bug(device, request, irb, sense[3]);
723 case 0x4e:
724 if (device->cdev->id.driver_info == tape_3490) {
725 /*
726 * Maximum block size exceeded. This indicates, that
727 * the block to be written is larger than allowed for
728 * buffered mode.
729 */
730 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The maximum block size"
731 " for buffered mode is exceeded\n");
732 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -ENOBUFS);
733 }
734 /* This erpa is reserved for 3480. */
735 return tape_34xx_erp_bug(device, request, irb, sense[3]);
736 case 0x50:
737 /*
738 * Read buffered log (Overflow). CU is running in extended
739 * buffered log mode, and a counter overflows. This should
740 * never happen, since we're never running in extended
741 * buffered log mode.
742 */
743 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
744 case 0x51:
745 /*
746 * Read buffered log (EOV). EOF processing occurs while the
747 * CU is in extended buffered log mode. This should never
748 * happen, since we're never running in extended buffered
749 * log mode.
750 */
751 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
752 case 0x52:
753 /* End of Volume complete. Rewind unload completed ok. */
754 if (request->op == TO_RUN) {
755 tape_med_state_set(device, MS_UNLOADED);
756 tape_34xx_delete_sbid_from(device, 0);
757 return tape_34xx_erp_succeeded(request);
758 }
759 return tape_34xx_erp_bug(device, request, irb, sense[3]);
760 case 0x53:
761 /* Global command intercept. */
762 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
763 case 0x54:
764 /* Channel interface recovery (temporary). */
765 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
766 case 0x55:
767 /* Channel interface recovery (permanent). */
768 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "A channel interface error cannot be"
769 " recovered\n");
770 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
771 case 0x56:
772 /* Channel protocol error. */
773 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "A channel protocol error "
774 "occurred\n");
775 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
776 case 0x57:
777 /*
778 * 3480: Attention intercept.
779 * 3490: Global status intercept.
780 */
781 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
782 case 0x5a:
783 /*
784 * Tape length incompatible. The tape inserted is too long,
785 * which could cause damage to the tape or the drive.
786 */
787 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape unit does not support "
788 "the tape length\n");
789 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
790 case 0x5b:
791 /* Format 3480 XF incompatible */
792 if (sense[1] & SENSE_BEGINNING_OF_TAPE)
793 /* The tape will get overwritten. */
794 return tape_34xx_erp_retry(request);
795 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape unit does not support"
796 " format 3480 XF\n");
797 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
798 case 0x5c:
799 /* Format 3480-2 XF incompatible */
800 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape unit does not support tape "
801 "format 3480-2 XF\n");
802 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EIO);
803 case 0x5d:
804 /* Tape length violation. */
805 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape unit does not support"
806 " the current tape length\n");
807 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EMEDIUMTYPE);
808 case 0x5e:
809 /* Compaction algorithm incompatible. */
810 dev_warn (&device->cdev->dev, "The tape unit does not support"
811 " the compaction algorithm\n");
812 return tape_34xx_erp_failed(request, -EMEDIUMTYPE);
813
814 /* The following erpas should have been covered earlier. */
815 case 0x23: /* Read data check. */
816 case 0x25: /* Write data check. */
817 case 0x26: /* Data check (read opposite). */
818 case 0x28: /* Write id mark check. */
819 case 0x31: /* Tape void. */
820 case 0x40: /* Overrun error. */
821 case 0x41: /* Record sequence error. */
822 /* All other erpas are reserved for future use. */
823 default:
824 return tape_34xx_erp_bug(device, request, irb, sense[3]);
825 }
826 }
827
---
0-DAY CI Kernel Test Service
https://lists.01.org/hyperkitty/list/kbuild-all@lists.01.org
Powered by blists - more mailing lists