Message-ID: <Zh-hASYS4XkyNJc9@ryzen>
Date: Wed, 17 Apr 2024 12:14:25 +0200
From: Niklas Cassel <cassel@...nel.org>
To: Gustav Ekelund <gustaek@...s.com>
Cc: Damien Le Moal <dlemoal@...nel.org>,
	Gustav Ekelund <gustav.ekelund@...s.com>, hare@...e.de,
	martin.petersen@...cle.com, linux-ide@...r.kernel.org,
	linux-kernel@...r.kernel.org, kernel@...s.com
Subject: Re: [PATCH] ata: Add sdev attribute to lower link speed in runtime

On Mon, Apr 15, 2024 at 04:49:46PM +0200, Gustav Ekelund wrote:
> On 4/13/24 02:29, Damien Le Moal wrote:
> > On 4/12/24 22:48, Gustav Ekelund wrote:
> >> Expose a new sysfs attribute to userspace that gives root the ability to
> >> lower the link speed in a scsi_device at runtime. The handle enables
> >> programs to, based on external circumstances that may be unbeknownst to
> >> the kernel, determine if a link should slow down to perhaps achieve a
> >> stabler signal. External circumstances could include the mission time
> >> of the connected hardware or observations to temperature trends.
> > 
> > may, perhaps, could... This does not sound very deterministic. Do you have an
> > actual practical use case where this patch is useful and solve a real problem ?
> > 
> > Strictly speaking, if you are seeing link stability issues due to temperature or
> > other environmental factors (humidity, altitude), then either you are operating
> > your hardware (board and/or HDD) outside of their environmental specifications,
> > or you have some serious hardware issues (which can be a simple as a bad SATA
> > cable or an inappropriate power supply). In both cases, I do not think that this
> > patch will be of any help.
> > 
> > Furthermore, libata already lowers a link speed automatically at runtime if it
> > sees too many NCQ errors. Isn't that enough ? And we also have the horkage flags
> > to force a maximum link speed for a device/adapter, which can also be specified
> > as a libata module argument (libata.force).
> > 
> >> Writing 1 to /sys/block/*/device/down_link_spd signals the kernel to
> >> first lower the link speed one step with sata_down_spd_limit and then
> >> finish off with sata_link_hardreset.
> > 
> > We already have "/sys/class/ata_link/*/hw_sata_spd_limit", which is read-only
> > for now. So if you can really justify this manual link speed tuning for an
> > actual use case (not a hypothetical one), then the way to go would be to make
> > that attribute RW and implement its store() method to lower the link speed at
> > runtime.
> > 
> > And by the way, looking at what that attribute says, I always get:
> > <unknown>
> > 
> > So it looks like there is an issue with it that went unnoticed (because no one
> > is using it...). This needs some fixing.
> > 
> Hello Damien and Niklas,
> 
> Thank you for the feedback.
> 
> I have a hotplug system, where the links behave differently depending
> on the disk model connected. For some models the kernel emits a lot of
> bus errors, but mostly not enough errors for it to automatically lower
> the link speed, except during high workloads. I have not observed any
> data-loss regarding the errors, but the excessive logging becomes a problem.

It might be interesting to compare the output of:
$ hdparm -I

for a drive that you can hot plug insert without errors, against a drive
that gives you errors on hot plug insertion, to see if this can give you
a hint of why they behave differently.

(e.g. certain features, e.g. DevSleep, is only enabled if there is support
in the HBA, the port, and the drive.)


Kind regards,
Niklas

Powered by blists - more mailing lists