Message-ID: <20140208091828.GA16336@glanzmann.de>
Date:	Sat, 8 Feb 2014 10:18:28 +0100
From:	Thomas Glanzmann <thomas@...nzmann.de>
To:	Eric Dumazet <edumazet@...gle.com>,
	"David S. Miller" <davem@...emloft.net>
Cc:	"Nicholas A. Bellinger" <nab@...ux-iscsi.org>,
	target-devel <target-devel@...r.kernel.org>,
	Linux Network Development <netdev@...r.kernel.org>,
	LKML <linux-kernel@...r.kernel.org>
Subject: REGRESSION f54b311142a92ea2e42598e347b84e1655caf8e3 tcp auto corking
 slows down iSCSI file system creation by factor of 70 [WAS: 4 TB VMFS
 creation takes 15 minutes vs 26 seconds]

Hello Eric,

> * Thomas Glanzmann <thomas@...nzmann.de> [2014-02-07 08:55]:
> > Creating a 4 TB VMFS filesystem over iSCSI takes 24 seconds on 3.12
> > and 15 minutes on 3.14.0-rc2+.

* Nicholas A. Bellinger <nab@...ux-iscsi.org> [2014-02-07 20:30]:
> Would it be possible to try a couple of different stable kernel
> versions to help track this down?

I bisected[1] it and found the offending commit f54b311 tcp auto corking
[2] 'if we have a small send and a previous packet is already in the
qdisc or device queue, defer until TX completion or we get more data.'
- Description by David S. Miller

I gathered a pcap with tcp_autocorking on and off.

On: - took 4 seconds to create a 500 GB VMFS file system
https://thomas.glanzmann.de/tmp/tcp_auto_corking_on.pcap.bz2
https://thomas.glanzmann.de/tmp/screenshot-mini-2014-02-08-09:45:43.png
https://thomas.glanzmann.de/tmp/screenshot-mini-2014-02-08-09:52:28.png

Off: - took 2 minutes 24 seconds to create a 500 GB VMFS file system
sysctl net.ipv4.tcp_autocorking=0
https://thomas.glanzmann.de/tmp/tcp_auto_corking_off.pcap.bz2
https://thomas.glanzmann.de/tmp/screenshot-mini-2014-02-08-09:46:34.png
https://thomas.glanzmann.de/tmp/screenshot-mini-2014-02-08-09:53:17.png

First graph can be generated by opening bunziping the file, opening it
in wireshark and select Statistics > IO Grap and change the unit to
Bytes/Tick. The second graph can be generated by selecting Statistics >
TCP Stream Graph > Round Trip Time.

You can also see that the round trip time increases by factor 25 at
least.

I once saw a similar problem with dealyed ACK packets of the
paravirtulized network driver in xen it caused that the tcp window
filled up and slowed down the throughput from 30 MB/s to less than 100
KB/s the symptom was that the login to a Windows desktop took more than
10 minutes while it used to be below 30 seconds because the profile of
the user was loaded slowly from a CIFS server. At that time the culprit
were also delayed small packets: ACK packets in the CIFS case. However I
only proofed iSCSI regression so far for tcp auto corking but assume we
will see many others if we leave it enabled.

I found the problem by doing the following:
        - I compiled kernel by executing the following commands:
                yes '' | make oldconfig
                time make -j 24
                / make modules_install
                / mkinitramfs -o /boot/initrd.img-bisect <version>

        - I cleaned the iSCSI configuration after each test by issuing:
                /etc/init.d/target stop
                rm /iscsi?/* /etc/target/*

        - I configured iSCSI after each reboot
                cat > lio-v101.conf <<EOF
set global auto_cd_after_create=false
/backstores/fileio create shared-01.v101.campusvl.de /iscsi1/shared-01.v101.campusvl.de size=500G buffered=true

/iscsi create iqn.2013-03.de.campusvl.v101.storage:shared-01.v101.campusvl.de
/iscsi/iqn.2013-03.de.campusvl.v101.storage:shared-01.v101.campusvl.de/tpgt1/portals create 10.101.99.4
/iscsi/iqn.2013-03.de.campusvl.v101.storage:shared-01.v101.campusvl.de/tpgt1/portals create 10.101.99.5
/iscsi/iqn.2013-03.de.campusvl.v101.storage:shared-01.v101.campusvl.de/tpgt1/portals create 10.102.99.4
/iscsi/iqn.2013-03.de.campusvl.v101.storage:shared-01.v101.campusvl.de/tpgt1/portals create 10.102.99.5
/iscsi/iqn.2013-03.de.campusvl.v101.storage:shared-01.v101.campusvl.de/tpgt1/luns create /backstores/fileio/shared-01.v101.campusvl.de lun=10
/iscsi/iqn.2013-03.de.campusvl.v101.storage:shared-01.v101.campusvl.de/tpgt1/ set attribute authentication=0 demo_mode_write_protect=0 generate_node_acls=1 cache_dynamic_acls=1

saveconfig
yes
EOF
                targetcli < lio-v101.conf
                And configured a fresh booted ESXi 5.5.0 1331820 via autodeploy
                to the iSCSI target, configured the portal, rescanned and
                created a 500 GB VMFS 5 filesystem and noticed the time if it
                was longer than 2 minutes it was bad if it was below 10 seconds
                it was good.
                git bisect good/bad

My network config is:

auto bond0
iface bond0 inet static
       address 10.100.4.62
       netmask 255.255.0.0
       gateway 10.100.0.1
       slaves eth0 eth1
       bond-mode 802.3ad
       bond-miimon 100

auto bond0.101
iface bond0.101 inet static
       address 10.101.99.4
       netmask 255.255.0.0

auto bond1
iface bond1 inet static
       address 10.100.5.62
       netmask 255.255.0.0
       slaves eth2 eth3
       bond-mode 802.3ad
       bond-miimon 100

auto bond1.101
iface bond1.101 inet static
       address 10.101.99.5
       netmask 255.255.0.0

I propose to disable tcp_autocorking by default because it obviously degrades
iSCSI performance and probably many other protocols. Also the commit mentions
that applications can explicitly disable auto corking we probably should do
that for the iSCSI target, but I don't know how. Anyone?

[1] http://pbot.rmdir.de/a65q6MjgV36tZnn5jS-DUQ
[2] https://git.kernel.org/cgit/linux/kernel/git/torvalds/linux.git/commit/?id=f54b311142a92ea2e42598e347b84e1655caf8e3

Cheers,
        Thomas
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe netdev" in
the body of a message to majordomo@...r.kernel.org
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html

Powered by blists - more mailing lists