Message-ID: <cbe9959a-7a8c-cab4-b7d0-6babd5a8234c@mojatatu.com>
Date:   Tue, 14 Mar 2023 18:24:19 -0300
From:   Pedro Tammela <pctammela@...atatu.com>
To:     netdev@...r.kernel.org
Cc:     jhs@...atatu.com, xiyou.wangcong@...il.com, jiri@...nulli.us,
        davem@...emloft.net, edumazet@...gle.com, kuba@...nel.org,
        pabeni@...hat.com
Subject: Re: [PATCH net-next v2 0/4] net/sched: act_pedit: minor improvements

On 14/03/2023 17:24, Pedro Tammela wrote:
> This series aims to improve the code and usability of act_pedit for
> netlink users.
> 
> Patch 1 improves error reporting for extended keys parsing with extack.
> While at it, do a minor refactor on error handling.
> 
> Patch 2 checks the static offsets a priori on create/update. Currently,
> this is done at the datapath for both static and runtime offsets.
> 
> Patch 3 removes a check from the datapath which is redundant since the
> netlink parsing validates the key types.
> 
> Patch 4 changes the 'pr_info()' calls in the datapath to rate limited
> versions.
> 
> v1->v2: Added patch 3 to the series as discussed with Simon.
> 
> Pedro Tammela (4):
>    net/sched: act_pedit: use extack in 'ex' parsing errors
>    net/sched: act_pedit: check static offsets a priori
>    net/sched: act_pedit: remove extra check for key type
>    net/sched: act_pedit: rate limit datapath messages
> 
>   net/sched/act_pedit.c | 77 +++++++++++++++++++------------------------
>   1 file changed, 33 insertions(+), 44 deletions(-)
> 

I forgot to add this to the cover letter:

1..70
ok 1 319a - Add pedit action that mangles IP TTL
ok 2 7e67 - Replace pedit action with invalid goto chain
ok 3 377e - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u32
ok 4 a0ca - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u32 (INVALID)
ok 5 dd8a - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u16 u16
ok 6 53db - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u16 (INVALID)
ok 7 5c7e - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u8 add value
ok 8 2893 - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u8 quad
ok 9 3a07 - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u8-u16-u8
ok 10 ab0f - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u16-u8-u8
ok 11 9d12 - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u32 set u16 clear u8 invert
ok 12 ebfa - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset overflow u32 (INVALID)
ok 13 f512 - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u16 at offmask shift set
ok 14 c2cb - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u32 retain value
ok 15 1762 - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u8 clear value
ok 16 bcee - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u8 retain value
ok 17 e89f - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u16 retain value
ok 18 c282 - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u32 clear value
ok 19 c422 - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u16 invert value
ok 20 d3d3 - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u32 invert value
ok 21 57e5 - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u8 preserve value
ok 22 99e0 - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u16 preserve value
ok 23 1892 - Add pedit action with RAW_OP offset u32 preserve value
ok 24 4b60 - Add pedit action with RAW_OP negative offset u16/u32 set value
ok 25 a5a7 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP eth set src
ok 26 86d4 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP eth set src & dst
ok 27 f8a9 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP eth set dst
ok 28 c715 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP eth set src (INVALID)
ok 29 8131 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP eth set dst (INVALID)
ok 30 ba22 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP eth type set/clear sequence
ok 31 dec4 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP eth set type (INVALID)
ok 32 ab06 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP eth add type
ok 33 918d - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP eth invert src
ok 34 a8d4 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP eth invert dst
ok 35 ee13 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP eth invert type
ok 36 7588 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip set src
ok 37 0fa7 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip set dst
ok 38 5810 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip set src & dst
ok 39 1092 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip set ihl & dsfield
ok 40 02d8 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip set ttl & protocol
ok 41 3e2d - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip set ttl (INVALID)
ok 42 31ae - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip ttl clear/set
ok 43 486f - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip set duplicate fields
ok 44 e790 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip set ce, df, mf, 
firstfrag, nofrag fields
ok 45 cc8a - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip set tos
ok 46 7a17 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip set precedence
ok 47 c3b6 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip add tos
ok 48 43d3 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip add precedence
ok 49 438e - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip clear tos
ok 50 6b1b - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip clear precedence
ok 51 824a - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip invert tos
ok 52 106f - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip invert precedence
ok 53 6829 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP beyond ip set dport & sport
ok 54 afd8 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP beyond ip set icmp_type & 
icmp_code
ok 55 3143 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP beyond ip set dport (INVALID)
ok 56 815c - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip6 set src
ok 57 4dae - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip6 set dst
ok 58 fc1f - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip6 set src & dst
ok 59 6d34 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip6 dst retain value (INVALID)
ok 60 94bb - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip6 traffic_class
ok 61 6f5e - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip6 flow_lbl
ok 62 6795 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP ip6 set payload_len, 
nexthdr, hoplimit
ok 63 1442 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP tcp set dport & sport
ok 64 b7ac - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP tcp sport set (INVALID)
ok 65 cfcc - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP tcp flags set
ok 66 3bc4 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP tcp set dport, sport & 
flags fields
ok 67 f1c8 - Add pedit action with LAYERED_OP udp set dport & sport
ok 68 d784 - Add pedit action with mixed RAW/LAYERED_OP #1
ok 69 70ca - Add pedit action with mixed RAW/LAYERED_OP #2
ok 70 abdc - Reference pedit action object in filter

Powered by blists - more mailing lists