[<prev] [next>] [<thread-prev] [thread-next>] [day] [month] [year] [list]
Message-ID: <20040319183919.GJ4016@hyper>
From: gadgeteer at elegantinnovations.org (gadgeteer@...gantinnovations.org)
Subject: Re: User Insecurity
On Thu, Mar 18, 2004 at 11:48:45AM -0600, Earl Keyser (Earl.Keyser@...zata.k12.mn.us) wrote:
> I think you folks miss the point.
>
> My VISA card doesn't have any bells and whistles to turn on or off -just
> a PIN to remember. My car is serviced by my mechanic. I don't know
> what's under the hood except where to put washer fluid. To ask me to
> make my own Visa card or tune my engine is an impossibility. My Dad is
> an MD - but he can't set the time on the VCR.
>
> Until the whole paradigm changes, we will live in an insecure world.
> Most home users are clueless - they want to remain that way. It's up to
> our industry (PC makers, OS makers, techies and researchers to build a
> better, safer mousetrap.
>
> Railing at the "clueless lusers" is both stupid and counter-productive.
What you describe regarding you and your mechanic is "blind trust".
You are trusting his abilities as a mechanic based on you preception
of him as a person.
OTOH, I learned the theory behind the design of the various systems that
comprise an automobile and got some hands on experience rebuilding
engines in high school auto shop. While I do not pretend to have the
working skills and knowledge to actually diagnose and repair a modern
auto I do have domain-specific knowledge which allows me to make informed
judgements of my mechanic's abilities by engaging him in conversation
regarding mechanics.
Likewise I have some interest in biology and expect the MD to explain
sufficiently so that I can fit what she is saying into my knowledge-base
without conflict.
Knowing proper food handling I can make reasonable judgement regarding a
restaurant and chances of food poisoning.
Just as "folk physics" and "folk psychology" can lead to erroneous
conclusions so too can limited knowledge-based judgements. However,
willful ignorance is simply a "kick me" sign hung on one's forehead
to a malicious social engineering attack.
Willful ignorance is "both stupid and counter-productive". Demands
for protection of the "clueless lusers" is merely shifting the burden
from those too f*****g lazy to be curious to the rest of us.
"Making something safe for idiots means only idiots will use it."
(It also makes it much more costly.)
--
Chief Gadgeteer
Elegant Innovations
Powered by blists - more mailing lists