Message-ID: <BF8D0CD7.EB9%alockhart@networkchemistry.com>
Date: Tue Nov  1 19:15:39 2005
From: alockhart at networkchemistry.com (Andrew Lockhart)
Subject: Gateway 7001 A/B/G AP: Selection of improper
 regulatory domains and channels

Issue: Gateway 7001 AP allows selection of restricted 802.11a/b/g channels
Author: Network Chemistry Labs <labs at networkchemistry dot com>
Vendor: Gateway 
Products: Gateway 7001 802.11 A/B/G Dual Band Wireless Access Point
Type: Input Validation
Exploit: Not required


I. Intro
The IEEE 802.11 family of standards define the channels that a
device is allowed to operate on for specific geographic regions in
order to comply with different country's radio frequency usage
regulations.


II. Vulnerability

The web management interface for the Gateway 7001 A/B/G AP contains an
input validation vulnerability that allows anyone authenticated
with the device's built-in web server to configure the device to
use channels not regulated for 802.11a/b/g use in their geographic
region.  The potential impact is that a user could configure the
device to operate outside the allocated bandwidth for 802.11
within their country, thus causing interference to other radio
systems.  In addition, the device will not be visible to other
802.11 devices operating in the area.


III. Details

The IEEE 802.11 standards provide guidance on the channels that a
device may operate on in order to comply with a country's radio
frequency usage regulations.  As is common on many access points,
the Gateway 7001 A/B/G AP provides a web based interface for configuring
the device.  This can be used to set the channel that the AP
operates on.

The POST form in the web-management interface used to set the
channel includes a form element called "RegulatoryDomain."
Through experimentation it appears that this parameter affects
input validation operations on the channel supplied in the
request. For example, if the regulatory domain parameter is set to
FCC, then the device's firmware will only change channels if the
channel value in the request is from 1 to 11.  Anything outside
this range, such as channel 13 (a European channel), will be
rejected.

However, if the regulatory domain parameter is changed, then the
firmware will allow the device's channel to be changed to any
channel allowed in the specified domain.  This can cause the
device to create interference with non-802.11 devices in the
vicinity as well as allow devices to be configured to elude 802.11
security walk-throughs by operating on frequencies that the
detection equipment is incapable of monitoring.


IV. Demonstration

In addition to POST requests, the web interface will accept the
same parameters in the form of a GET requeset. The web-based
management software for the Gateway 7001 A/B/G AP uses a request string
of the following form to set configuration parameters:

http://192.168.2.1/index.cgi?r1Mode=IEEE+802.11g&r1RegulatoryDomain=FCC&r1Ch
annel=1&r2Mode=IEEE+802.11a&r2RegulatoryDomain=FCC&r2Channel=36&r1b1s1Ssid=N
etChemLabs&r1b2s1Ssid=NetChemLabs-Guest&page=wireless.html&Update=Update

To change the frequencies of operation available all that needs to
be done is to simply change the RegulatoryDomain parameter.  For
instance to operate on Japanese channels, the string "FCC" would
be changed to "MKK."  This allows the channel parameters
corresponding to the 802.11b/g and 802.11a radios to be changed to
channels such as 14 and 34 respectively, which the management
software will apply to the underlying hardware:

http://192.168.2.1/index.cgi?r1Mode=IEEE+802.11g&r1RegulatoryDomain=MKK&r1Ch
annel=14&r2Mode=IEEE+802.11a&r2RegulatoryDomain=MKK&r2Channel=34&r1b1s1Ssid=
NetChemLabs+&r1b2s1Ssid=NetChemLabs-Guest&page=wireless.html&Update=Update

It was also verified that European channels were settable when
changing the RegulatoryDomain parameter to "ETSI."  To verify that
the device is indeed operating on non-FCC channels, special 802.11
sensor hardware was used to monitor the device on the specified
channels.

The Gateway 7001 A/B/G AP makes use of DeviceScape's Instant802 Wireless
Infrastructure Platform for configuration and management.  It is
unknown at this time whether this issue affects other devices
utilizing this software, due to the fact that we have only tested
the Gateway 7001 A/B/G AP at this point. Gateway also produces an
802.11 b/g version of the Gateway 7001 AP.  It is also unknown whether
this model is affected.

It should be noted that Gateway does not provide a firmware upgrade
for the affected AP.


V. Timeline

10/21 - Contacted Gateway: No response received
10/21 - Contacted DeviceScape: No response received
10/4 - Contacted Gateway: No response received
9/28 - Contacted DeviceScape to confirm they had observed the issue: No
reponse received
9/26 - Contacted Gateway: No response received
9/21 - Made contact with Gateway Support: told someone would follow-up
9/20 - Received follow-up response from DeviceScape
9/19 - Made contact with DeviceScape


VI. References

Gateway 7001 A/B/G AP product support page:
http://support.gateway.com/s/Servers/COMPO/NETWORK/7005082/7005082nv.shtml

Instant802 WIP product page:
http://www.devicescape.com/products/wip_landing.php


--
Andrew Lockhart <alockhart@...workchemistry.com>
Security Analyst, Network Chemistry
PGP Key ID: 58369156
Fingerprint: 0AE1 E826 1922 5453 2B34  E1AA F524 D20B 5836 9156

Powered by blists - more mailing lists